Why the Popularity? A Big Bang Theory

I know it’s very cool to put-down The Big Bang Theory, especially after the recent news that it’s finally coming to an end in 2019.

I just want to let everyone know that you’re not being clever by disrespecting a show that hasn’t contained a single joke since 2011. It’s not “big” of you to point out that the actors have looked dead behind the eyes for the last few years. And you’re certainly not breaking new ground by saying that The Big Bang Theory is the single reason that talented comedy writers won’t be attempting a studio sitcom for decades to come.

I, however, am all of those things.

To quote Sheldon, “All of you are just being Bazzingered right now!”


There’s no denying that Big Bang is popular. Averaging 18.6 million viewers in the twilight days of broadcast television is no small feat. I also can’t deny that the show was passible and borderline decent in its first few seasons. It’s rare that a studio sitcom has “perfect” seasons (see Seinfeld, Cheers, Frasier and IT Crowd for more details) but decent should be a solid benchmark for a staple comedy genre.

Big Bang achieved this early on, but rapidly spiralled into a decline fuelled by reference humour, half-arsed gags, sitcom cliche and borderline ableism. It’s the sort of sitcom that in — theory — should’ve been on the air for five or six seasons.

But that’s not what happened, and like everything else that doesn’t make a lick of sense in this confusing world — I had to know why.

I don’t mean to brag, but I have a totally useless Film and Media degree. On this course I wrote several essays on sitcoms and comedy, as well as writing eleven sitcom screenplays myself (either for my course or in my own time, like a freak).

I’m not saying I know more about comedy than the writers of Big Bang, but I probably know more than its average viewer.


Before you start, I know that comedy is purely subjective; One person’s comedic cup of tea is not going to be the same as the other person’s hot chocolate served in an abstract clown-shoe. However, scripted comedy for television, well — there’s almost a science to it. Particularly in America.

Over twenty episodes need to be produced each year, which is a pretty mammoth task. Especially after the first batch of original ideas you’ve been working on for years dries up. Usually with a writers room of funny people, the jokes keep on flowing for years to come, but the story structure becomes weak, tired and uninspired.

The Simpsons is a great example of this. If you put on an episode from the last fifteen years, I guarantee you’ll laugh at a stand-alone joke that wouldn’t be out of place in a classic episode. However, the plot will be forced and barely make any sense, thus reducing the overall quality to worse than if it had never been made.

I don’t want to generalise, but I absolutely will — The people who tend to watch Big Bang don’t typically like many other comedy shows. They’ll laugh at the non-jokes, in time with the laugh track, leaving everyone else bewildered by what was so funny.

Here’s a scene with the laugh-track removed, these are the lines that made it through the writers room.

I watched an episode of Big Bang from season eleven recently and it was completely devoid of any jokes; A vacuum for humour. One of the punchlines was “Sheldon” and another one was “But Superman?” — and, shockingly, another punchline was autism.

The characters were moving along at a decent pace though, going through the motions of any TV family. By the end of the episode, Sheldon had actually grown as a person and the relationship between Leonard and Penny had been tested.

That’s when it hit me — This isn’t a sitcom, it’s a soap opera.

The near-nineteen-million people who watch Big Bang aren’t doing so for the jokes; Simply by watching the show they prove that they have zero interest in comedy. No, they’re sitting down for a half hour every week to follow the lives of seven fictional people who they can look down on in order to feel better about themselves — just like a soap opera!

The viewing figures all make sense now. Soaps still draw huge numbers because people are invested in the lives of the characters. Big Bang stopped being a comedy around eight years ago, but they managed to keep its characters progressing at such a pace that people would still be along for the ride.

And I cannot criticise them for that, as it’s clearly what they set-out to achieve.

Now, if you’ll allow me, I’d like to present the leaked script for the final scene of The Big Bang Theory:


Leonard and Sheldon enter and are about to begin climbing the stairs.

Leonard: Hey look Sheldon, the elevators fixed.

Sheldon: Well it’s about time.

Leonard: It’s been what — twelve years?

Leonard pushes the button and waits for the elevator, he looks over at Sheldon.

Leonard: Twelve long years.

The doors open and Leonard enters the elevator. Sheldon remains in the hallway.

Leonard: Come on Sheldon — I’ve rented Superman three for our last night in the apartment together.

Sheldon: (Hesitating) I think I’ll take the stairs.

Leonard: (Holding the doors open) Oh now — come on Sheldon. You’ve changed jobs, got married and now you’re about to become a father — and you’re telling me you can’t just get inside an elevator?

Sheldon looks around, from the floor to the elevator to the ceiling, and then back to Leonard.

Sheldon: Yes that’s exactly what I’m telling you.

Leonard: Fine, I guess I’ll see you up there.

Sheldon: I guess you will.

They smile at each other as the doors close. It’s warm, friendly even, as though they’re both sharing in the memory of twelve years spent living together.

Sheldon remains in the hallway, looking at the elevator. Beat.

Sheldon whips out a walkie-talkie and holds down the talk button.

Sheldon: Okay — Now Amy!

He smiles wickedly as we hear Leonard’s screams from the elevator shaft. The screams eventually fade into silence.

Amy (on walkie): Did it work?

Sheldon: Yes. That’s Leonard incinerated — Now let’s go get the others.

Sheldon puts the walkie in his pocket. He goes to exit the apartment building, but turns around in the doorway to look at the elevator.

Sheldon: (Cold) Bazinga — Motherf***er.

Roll credits.

Today is Thursday, August 23rd and remind me to look at this post in May 2019, just in case this is how it all ends and CBS owes me money.

Tip My Jar?

If you like what I write and can spare a dollar, then it’d be a greatly appreciated act of kindness! If you like what I write and can’t spare a dollar then I greatly appreciate you! If you hate what I write and also can’t spare a dollar, then why are you still reading this?


6 thoughts on “Why the Popularity? A Big Bang Theory

  1. Very interesting. I have never watched TBBT, but I can tell you why I kept watching Lost, even after it turned south.


    I sat down at the same time, with the same friends, for the same amount of time, to see the same characters. It became routine, a nice habit to share with friends and laugh and complain about the plot. After so many years of doing so, it seemed weird not to.

    I watched The Walking Dead alone and at random times, and as soon as the plot sagged, I stopped watching it. So maybe there’s some element of routine/habit/familiarity to TBBT, too.


    Liked by 1 person

    1. I have to agree with that, it’s almost ritualistic for some people.

      More importantly, I have to jump on the mention of you being a Lostie!

      I’m also a huge Lost fan, even after the decline in quality. Myself, my wife and our friend are currently in the process of recording a re-watch/revisit podcast for Lost, to start releasing in 2019 for the 15th anniversary year.

      It’s definitely a show that I formed a habit with back in the day, discussing it with friends at school and college after it aired.

      It’s so strange to think that Big Bang Theory started when Lost was between seasons 3 and 4, yet TBBT is still on TV to this day.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Lost was incredibly interesting, with so many ethical dilemmas and awesome character development!

        If I’m not mistaken, the writer’s strike back in ’08 interrupted Lost? That might account for the decline in… I don’t want to say ‘quality,’ but it seemed that once they introduced time-travel, they bit off too much.

        Still, there’s a nostalgic soft spot in my heart for Lost 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Yeah! So much philosophy below the surface as well.

        It definitely effected it, and season 5’s time travel is what turned a lot of people off. I’ll defend it, because I’m a Lost apologist. People wanted answers to all the Dharma questions, and the only way they were going to get it all in detail was via characters living in that world (unless they did a 4 Episode flashback or something) While it wasn’t perfect, and the characterisation fell short of the high benchmark of the first couple of seasons, I think it was necessary.

        So much nostalgia! 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I thought TBBT was great for the first few seasons, because that’s when it remained true to the original idea of 4 nerdy guys and a hot girl next door. But when they brought in Amy and Bernadette it really started to go downhill. I lost interest after the 5th season and it’s really about time they wrap the show up. They’ve ran through every possible idea.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s